In the world of specialty coffee, the bean is often treated as the protagonist. We talk endlessly about the origin, the altitude, the processing method, and the roast profile. But if the bean is the actor, the brewing method is the director. The way you choose to introduce water to coffee determines how the story is told.
You can take the exact same single-origin Ethiopian bean, brew it in a French Press, and then brew it in a V60. The result? Two completely different beverages. One might be heavy, chocolatey, and bold; the other tea-like, floral, and vibrant.
Broadly speaking, manual brewing falls into two philosophical camps: Immersion and Percolation (Pour-Over). Understanding the physics and flavor distinctions between these two styles will help you choose the right tool for your palate—and your mood.
The Contender: Immersion Brewing
Examples: French Press, AeroPress (standard), Clever Dripper, Cold Brew, Cupping.
The Mechanism
Immersion is the oldest and most intuitive way to make coffee. It involves fully submerging coffee grounds in water and letting them steep together for a set period. It is similar to making tea. The water and coffee hang out in the same vessel until you decide the brewing is done, at which point you separate them (usually with a mesh filter).
The Physics of Extraction
In immersion brewing, extraction happens through osmosis and diffusion. At the beginning, the water is fresh and extracts flavor aggressively. However, as the water becomes saturated with coffee solids, its ability to extract slows down. This creates a “saturation curve.” It is very difficult to over-extract immersion coffee because the water eventually just stops pulling flavor out as it gets “full.”
The Flavor Profile: Body and Richness
Immersion methods typically use a metal mesh filter (like in a French Press). Metal filters do not catch everything. They allow oils (lipids) and microscopic coffee particles (fines) to pass into your cup.
-
Mouthfeel: The presence of oils coats your tongue, creating a heavy, velvety, and creamy texture.
-
Taste: The flavor tends to be “rounded” and integrated. You get less clarity on specific flavor notes, but you get more “bass notes”—chocolate, nuts, and caramel.
-
The Experience: Comfort. A French Press brew is cozy, forgiving, and robust.
Best Practices for Immersion
-
Don’t Rush: Since extraction slows down over time, immersion requires patience. A 4-minute brew is standard, but many pros recommend 8 or even 10 minutes for a French Press to allow the silt to settle.
-
Break the Crust: After 4 minutes, a “crust” of grounds will form on top. Stir it gently. Most grounds will sink. Scoop off the remaining foam for a cleaner taste.
-
Grind Coarse: To avoid a muddy cup, keep your grind size similar to sea salt.
The Contender: Pour-Over (Percolation)
Examples: Hario V60, Chemex, Kalita Wave, Melitta.
The Mechanism
Percolation involves water passing through a bed of coffee. You pour fresh water on top, gravity pulls it through the grounds, and it drips out the bottom into a carafe. The water is constantly moving.
The Physics of Extraction
Unlike immersion, where the water gets saturated, pour-over constantly introduces fresh, clean water to the coffee. Fresh water is an aggressive solvent. This means extraction happens efficiently and continues as long as you keep pouring. This makes pour-over less forgiving—if you pour too much or too slowly, you can easily extract bitterness. However, when done right, it extracts compounds that immersion misses.
The Flavor Profile: Clarity and Complexity
Pour-over methods almost exclusively use paper filters. Paper is dense; it traps the coffee oils and the microscopic sediment that metal filters let through.
-
Mouthfeel: The resulting cup is clean, light, and tea-like. It lacks the heavy body of a French Press.
-
Taste: Without the heavy oils masking the palate, the “high notes” shine. You perceive acidity more sharply. Floral aromas, citrus notes, and berry flavors become distinct and separated. This is called Flavor Clarity.
-
The Experience: Refinement. Pour-over is about exploring the nuance of a high-quality bean.
Best Practices for Pour-Over
-
The Bloom: Always start by wetting the grounds with a small amount of water (2x the weight of the coffee) and waiting 30–45 seconds. This releases CO2 gas. If you don’t bloom, the gas pushes water away, leading to uneven extraction.
-
Pour Technique: Use a gooseneck kettle. You need a slow, steady stream. Pour in circles to agitate the grounds evenly.
-
Grind Medium: You want resistance, but not a clog. Think sand or kosher salt.
The Hybrid: AeroPress & Clever Dripper
If you can’t decide, there are brewers that straddle the line.
-
The Clever Dripper combines the two. You steep the coffee (immersion) but then place it on a cup, which opens a valve and filters it through paper (percolation/filtering). You get the body of immersion with the clean finish of a paper filter.
-
The AeroPress is the chameleon. It is technically immersion, but uses pressure and a paper filter. It can mimic an espresso, a pour-over, or a French press depending on your recipe.
Which Should You Choose?
The “better” method depends entirely on what you value in your cup and what beans you are buying.
Choose Immersion (French Press) if:
-
You enjoy a full-bodied, strong cup of coffee.
-
You add milk or cream (the heavy body stands up well to dairy).
-
You are drinking darker roasts, chocolatey blends, or lower-acidity beans (like Sumatra or Brazil).
-
You want a simple, “set it and forget it” routine.
Choose Pour-Over (V60/Chemex) if:
-
You prefer a clean, light, and refreshing cup.
-
You drink your coffee black.
-
You invest in light-roast, Single Origin beans (especially washed coffees from Ethiopia, Kenya, or Colombia).
-
You enjoy the ritual of the pour and want to control every variable.
Conclusion
Ultimately, a true coffee enthusiast doesn’t just pick one side. They build a toolkit. There are mornings when you need the comforting, thick embrace of a French Press. There are other mornings when you want to meditate over the complex floral aromatics of a V60.
The beautiful thing about home brewing is the ability to experiment. Try brewing the same bean both ways. Taste them side-by-side. You will realize that the “flavor” of coffee is not a fixed point, but a spectrum of possibilities waiting for you to unlock.